Purusha-Prakrithi Jnanam

Gita essays – 23

Arjuna wanted to know from Lord Krishna about the six technical terms used in Vedanta; Kshertam, Kshetrajna, Jnanam, Jneyam, Prakrithi and Purusha. After explaining the first four terms Lord starts talking about Prakrithi and Purusha from verse 20 of chapter 13.  Lord has already explained in Chapter7 (Gita essays-11) the two aspects of His nature as Brahman; Para prakrithi, the higher principle and Apara prakrithi the lower principle and both of them are beginningless and eternal.  He has also further revealed that the changing matter principle constitutes the Apara prakrithi and the changeless Consciousness principle the Para prakrithi.  Now in this chapter Lord is talking about Apara prakrithi as Prakrithi and Para prakrithi as Purusha,  So from this we can see that both Purusha and Prakrithi are beginningless and also that both of them together constitute the cause of the universe.

Everything in the creation is born out of Prakr̥thi and this includes the body, mind complex also.  Not only the body- mind complex but also all the conditions of the body-mind complex, favourable and unfavourable like pleasure and pain, form part of the Prakrithi.  Purusha, as the unchanging witness lending sentiency to the body-mind complex, appears to experience all the conditions of body-mind complex as a silent witness associated with the body-mind complex. So Lord explains in verse 23 “Purusha dwelling in the body is the same as Supreme. He is also called as the Witness, the Approver, the Supporter, the Experiencer (as the embodied Purusha), the great Lord and the Supreme Self”.  Purusha, as Supreme is everywhere including every Prakrithi enclosure of body.  We can see from this that Purusha is one and changeless, Prakrithi is many and changing; Purusha is attributeless. Prakrithi is with attributes; Purusha is beyond the influence of three Gunas, Satvam, Rajas and Tamas, Prakrithi functions under the influence of the three Gunas. 

Lord has pointed out earlier in verse 2 & 3, “This body is termed as Kshetra  and ---------- Know Myself as Kshetrajna in all Kshetras”   From this we can see that both Purusha and Kshetrajna are synonyms and refer to Athma and both  Prakrithi and Kshetra are synonyms and refer to anathma.  Lord has also stated earlier in verse 3 “O Arjuna! Knowledge of both the Kshetra(Prakrithi) and the Kshetrjna(Purusha) is considered by Me to be the Real knowledge”. Under Jnanam Lord had earlier discussed only the moral qualities and virtues that prepare the mind for  assimilating the Jnanam.  And now Lord gives more of the knowledge of Kshetram (Prakrithi) and Kshtrajna (Purusha) and the benefit of this Jnanam, which He calls Real knowledge..

In verse 27 Lord states “Whatever being, moving or stationary, is born --- know that to be out of the union of Kṣhetram (Prakrithi) and Khṣetrajna (Purusha), Oh, Arjuna !”

The union between the Prakrithi and Purusha is not of any physical kind or of any material nature but it is one of superimposition, called Adhyasa.  In every superimposition a delusion is recognized upon the substratum just like a ghost on the post where the non-existent ghost comes into existence and the existing post gives place to non-existent ghost.  Here the Prakrithi which has no independent existence and so mithya is superimposed on Purusha, Pure consciousness, which only has independent existence and is Satyam. This relationship conjures up the phenomenon of the material world, consisting of the moving and non-moving and also the insentient body being mistaken for the sentient Self and vice versa. This confusion is cleared when the illusion disappears due to Jnanam, the knowledge of Purusha and Prakrithi. So Lord states in the next verse, verse 28, “He who sees the supreme Lord who dwells alike in all beings and who is imperishable as the unperishing within the perishing, (alone really) sees”.

Samsara and resultant cycle of birth and death occurs due to ignorance of Real knowledge (Jnanam).  Lord calls this cycle as destroying Self by self and remarks that this Real knowledge, Jnanam, frees one from this cycle.  Jnanam consists of seeing that all actions are performed by Prakrithi alone and Purusha is actionless and that  Purusha is only the witness, not the doer; the spectator, not the actor.  This Jnanam is complete when one understands that the multiplicity of names and forms arise from the Purusha only and spread to become the Universe. In short as Kaivalya Upanishad (1-19) says “In me alone everything is born; in me does everything rest; and in me is everthing dissolved.  I am that Brahman (Purusha) secondless.”  The same is echoed in the Chandogya Upanishad (VII.xxvi.1) “From the Self (Purusha) is life, from the Self is desire, from the Self is love, from the Self is akasa, from the Self is light, from the Self are the waters --------”. When the variety of nature and its development are traced to the Eternal One, one assumes eternity. He realizes the all pervading nature of the Self, as the cause of all limitation has been destroyed by the knowledge of unity with Brahman and he becomes a Jivanmuktha.

Lord also states in verse 32 “Being birthless and attributeless, this supreme Self is changeless. Though dwelling in the body, it neither acts nor is affected.”  In next two verses 33 & 34, Lord compares Purusha with space and sun to illustrate the point that Purusha is one only and is unaffected by the activities of Prakrithi though it is closely associated with it as Self in the body. “Just as the all pervading space is not affected due to its subtlety, so also, the Self (Purusha), which is present in everybody (Prakrithi), is not affected.  (13-33).   “Just as one Sun illumines the entire world, so also does the Kshetrajna (Purusha) illumines the entire Kṣhetraṁ (Prakrithi), O Arjuna.”  (13-34).

Space is the subtlest of all gross elements and hence pervades everything that is grosser than it. Though everything remain in it, yet nothing that it contains can contaminate it. Brahman, the Supreme Self which is the cause of the very Space is subtler than Space. So Brahman (Purusha) pervades all and nothing pervades It and It is not affected by anything that exists or is happening in the world of plurality. Just like the sun, the Consciousness merely illumines the world of objects, the body, the mind and the intellect. Lighting of the world by the sun is not an activity undertaken by sun as light itself is the very nature of the sun and in its light everything gets illumined. Similarly, the nature of Consciousness is awareness and in Its presence everything becomes known i.e., illumined. The sun illumines everything, good and bad, beautiful and ugly, virtue and vice etc. So too, in our inner life, Consciousness functions through body equipments and illumines them but never gets contaminated by the actions of the body or by the emotions of the mind or by the thoughts of the intellect.

Those who imbibe this Jnanam regarding Purusha and Prakrithi and liberation from Prakrithi, through steadfast and sincere practice of either Jnana Yoga or Dhyana Yoga or Karma Yoga or Bhakthi Yoga, attain the Supreme, assures the Lord before discussing this Jnanam. 

-----------------------------

Sankara Bhagavatpada -2

Philosophy of Advaita

Sri Sankara Bhagavatpada is the principal, though not the first, exponent of the Advaita Vedanta, and he systematised the works of preceding philosophers. “The Advaita taught by Sri Sankara is a rigorous, absolute one” observes Swami Sivananda. Bhagavatpada was the exponent of the Kevala Advaita philosophy.  His teachings can be summed up in the following words: “Brahma Satyam Jagat Mithya, Jeevo Brahmaiva Na Aparah” - Brahman alone is real, this world is unreal; the Jeeva is identical with Brahman. So a correct understanding of his usage of the terms, Brahman, Satyam, Jagat, Mithya and Jeeva is necessary for proper comprehension of his philosophy.  His philosophy is based on Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita and Brahma Sutras and so his Bhashyas of the Prasthana thrayi form the central texts in understanding his philosophy.

As per Bhagavatpada’s philosophy there are three orders of Satyam, reality, viz., Paramarthika Satyam (absolue reality), Vyavaharika Satyam (relative reality or transactional reality.) and Pratibhashika Satyam (reflective reality).  Absolute reality is the unchanging Reality that does not undergo any change in all three times; past, present and future and is always the same. This is the Pure Existence defined in Upanishads as Sat and that is Brahman. Vyavaharika Satyam is the transactional or empirical reality. This has experienceability, transactability and utility but has no absolute Reality and that is the Universe. Reality of day and night is an example of Vyavaharika Satyam.  Pratibhasika Satyam is apparent reality like the mirage water, seen as water but not available for use as water. Object/event experienced in dream is an example of Prathibasika Satyam.

Brahman, Paramathma, is Nirguna, without Gunas, Nirakara, formless, and Nirvisesha, without attributes, and impersonal and it is Sat, Chit, Ananda i.e. Existence, Knowledge, Bliss, in their absolute pure nature. Sat, Chit, Anandha constitute the intrinsic nature of Brahman and should not be treated as attributes.  Nirguna Brahman has the unmanifest power, Maya.  Bhagavatpada describes Maya in Vivekachudamani in verses 110 and 111 thus:

Maya is the power of the limitless Lord. It is anadhi (beginningless) avidya and is of the nature of three Gunas viz. Satva, Rajas, and Tamas and is superior to their effects (as their cause).  Its existence can be inferred from its effects only, by one who has subtle intellect.  It is the Maya through which the whole world is born.   (110)  

Maya cannot be described as either existent (Sat) or non-existent (asat) or as a combination of both; as either separate or non-separate from Brahman or as a combination of both; as either having parts or as partless or as a combination of both.  It is a great wonder and is anirvachaneeya (cannot be categorically described).   (111)

Brahman  with this inscrutable, undefinable power of Maya manifest is called Saguna Brahman or Iswara. Saguna Brahman and Nirguna Brahman are not two Brahmans, one the antithesis of other. It is the same Brahman from two different points of view, one Paramarthika point and the other Vyavaharika point.  Nirguna Brahman with power of Maya manifest appears as Saguna Brahman, Iswara and Iswara is the personal God whom the devotees worship. So the question of superiority or inferiority does not arise between the two though one maybe called Para Brahman and the other apara Brahman to distinguish between impersonal and personal Supreme.

Mithya is not illusion, it is vyavaharika satyam. So Jagat, the Universe, a product of Maya, is not an illusion. As vyavaharika satyam it is available for experience, transactions and is useful but it is not absolutely Real, and it is only the unchanging Brahman that appears as the changing Universe through Maya. Maya through its two powers, avarana sakthi, veiling power and vikshepa sakthi, projecting power, veils the unchanging Brahman and projects the changing universe as adhyasa.  As the unchanging Brahman only appears as the changing universe through Maya the universe has no independent Reality and hence Mithya. 

Jeevathma, is the real Self of the individual, Jeeva, who is a combination of Self, Jeevathma, and non-Self, anathma. The entire body-mind-intellect complex is anathama and material and Jeevathma is the life force that lends sentiency to anathama through its manifestation in anathma.  Jeevathma is Pure Consciousness, Chaitanyam, and is not different from Brahman, Paramathma.  Maya as anadhi avidya masks Jeeva’s real nature as Brahman and projects anathma as its real nature. Under the influence of  avidya an individual Jeeva mistakes its real nature as anathma instead of as Jeevathma.  Avidya includes not only ignorance but also erroneous knowledge. So the individual Jeeva thinks it is finite, limited and separate from Paramathma and other Jeevas and suffers samsara. Moksha or Liberation is ending the influence of avidya through Jnanam and realising one’s essential nature as Brahman. When one acquires the knowledge of one’s true Self as Brahman and is firmly rooted in that knowledge, avidya ends and one attains Jeevanmukthi, liberation while living. The identity of Jeevathma with Paramathma, called JeevaBrahma Ikyam, is an important aspect of Sri Sankara Bhagavatpada’s philosophy. 

Another important aspect of the philosophy is adhyasa.  Adhyasa means superimposition or false attribution of properties of one thing on another. For example, when a rope is mistaken for a snake in dim light, there is adhyasa of snake on the rope. It produces the same effect on the seer as the real snake, the reaction of fear etc. This reaction of fear etc. lasts so long as no light is shone on the rope and when light is shone, its real nature is discovered and fear etc. goes.  In the case of Jeeva there is mutual adhyasa between anathma, body-mind complex, and Athma, so that the intrinsic nature of Existence and Consciousness are attributed to anathma and actions and experiences of anathma are attributed to Athma, which is really akartha and aboktha. So the empirical ego is mistaken for transcendental ego causing samsara.  With spiritual enlightenment, adhyasa ends and samsara goes. 

So in a nutshell, in Kevala Advaita, Athma is one only without a second.  Free of all upadhis and with Maya unmanifest, it is called Brahman. With universe as upadhi and Maya manifest, it is called Iswara.  With Maya active and adhyasa operating, it is called the efficient and material cause of the universe.  With Sareera Thriam as upadhi and with Maya as Avidya, it is called the Jeeva.  But only the upadhiless Athma, that is Brahman, is absolutely and unconditionally Real, all else either relatively Real or apparently Real, if not unreal. 

----------------