Purva Mimamsa and Uttara Mimamsa
Mimamsa
means to analyze and understand thoroughly.
Purva Mimamsa emphasises the
teachings of Veda in the light of rituals (Karma
kanda), while Uttara Mimamsa
emphasises the teachings of the Veda in the light of knowledge (Jnana kanda). We shall hereafter refer to Purva Mimamsa as Mimamsa only
and to Uttara Mimamsa with its emphasis on anta bhagha of Vedas as Vedanta only.
Mimamsa
The Mimamsa Sutras of Jaimini is the basic text of this system. The main objective of this school was to establish the authority of the Vedas. Its adherents called Mimamsakas believed that:
The Mimamsa Sutras of Jaimini is the basic text of this system. The main objective of this school was to establish the authority of the Vedas. Its adherents called Mimamsakas believed that:
(1) there is a soul
which survives the death of the body and enjoys the fruits of the rituals
in heaven;
(2) the Vedas are
infallible;
(3) this world is
real;
To justify the
supreme authority of the Vedas, the Mimamsa
school has developed an
elaborate epistemology which has been accepted by other schools also, including the
Vedānta Darshana. It accepts all the six Pramanas;
Pratyaksha, Anupalabdhi, Anumana,
Upamana, Arthapathi, Sabda or Apta-vakhya and lays down the following three
conditions for knowledge to be valid:
(1) It should yield
some new information previously unknown.
(2) It should not be
contradicted by any other knowledge.
(3) The conditions
which generate that knowledge should be free from defects.
The Mimamsa school
believes in the reality of the world with all the myriad objects in it. This
world, according to it, comprises the living bodies, wherein the souls (Jivas) reside temporarily to reap the
effects of their karmas, good or bad. The various other objects of the world
serve as the fruits to be suffered or enjoyed. The souls are infinite and
eternal but undergo transmigration due to their karmas performed when encased
in bodies in the world. The soul has no consciousness of its own. Consciousness
only rises in it due to its association with the mind, the sense-organs and the
sense-objects, especially when the organs come into contact with their
respective objects and cites the absence of consciousness in the deep-sleep state
as the proof. A ritual is to be done because the Vedas command it and none has
the choice not to do it or to do it in a different way. Such duties are classified
into two broad groups: nitya or daily obligatory duties and naimithika or
occasional (but obligatory) duties. These help in the purification of the soul
through moral improvement. The ultimate goal for a person is to get mokṣa or
liberation which is defined as total cessation of
transmigratory existence. In this state the soul is permanently free from all pain and
suffering though there is no consciousness or bliss! Since all the materials that make up the
physical world are eternally existing and since the karmas of the souls impel
these materials in the process of creation, there is no need to accept any God
as the agent or author of creation. So this system that champions the supremacy
of the Vedas has no place for its Source! This system also discusses the
science of sound and Mantra in detail. Its
influence can be seen in the performance of Hindu rituals and in observance of religious
practices even today. It was also
influential and foundational to Vedanta
school.
Vedanta
The
Vedanta system is based on Upanishads, Brahmasutras and Bhagavad Gita, referred
to as Sruthi-prasthana, Nyaya-prasthana and Smrithi-prasthana respectively and Prasthanathraya collectively. While Mimamsa Sutras of Jaimini tries to reconcile the various Vedic
texts that seem to give different directions with regard to the same ritual
system, Brahma Sutras of Vyasa
attempts to make out a coherent philosophy of Brahman from the apparently conflicting statements in the Upanishads.
But Brahma Sutras and the Upanishads themselves were variously interpreted by Vedanta scholars giving rise to many
sub-schools. We shall see here briefly the three popular sub-schools of Vedanta
viz. Advaita of Sri Sankara, Visishtadvaita of Sri Ramanuja and Dvaita of Sri
Madhva
Advaita of Sri Sankara –
Sri Sankara sums up his Advaita philosophy in a nutshell as “Brahma satyam jagan mithya jivo brahmaiva
naparah” - Brahman alone is Real;
this world is not Real and the Jiva
is verily Brahman only and is not different from Him. Apart from Brahman, which
only is the absolutely Reality, all others are only transactional Realities i.e. Real
only under certain conditions and circumstances and not at all times. In his
essential nature which is Pure Consciousness, Jiva is one with Brahman which is Pure Consciousness infinite.
Brahman has no limiting adjuncts and is Nirguna. Maya is a unique concept of this philosophy. Maya is the power of the limitless Lord. It is anadhi (beginningless)
avidya and is of the nature of three Gunas
viz. Satva, Rajas, and Tamas and is superior to their effects. With
His power of Maya manifest, Brahman
is Saguna and is called Iswara and it is Iswara who is the, srishti,
sthithi laya karanam and also the upadhana
karanam (material cause) and nimitha karanam
(efficient cause) for the world, without undergoing any changes Himself, like
the spider for its web and ourselves for our dream-world. The multiplicity of
names and forms is only an appearance, due to avidya or ignorance, even as a snake is perceived in a rope in
insufficient light. This is called `adhyasa'
or `adhyaropa' (superimposition).
Through Vidya or discriminative
knowledge, `apavada' or
desuper-imposition takes place, giving the true knowledge of the underlying Reality
of all objects seen and experienced as Brahman only. Liberation is the realisation of one’s true
Self as Brahman only, which is one
without a second, that can be attained even when alive. This state of liberation while alive is
termed Jivanmukthi.
Visishtadvaita of Sri
Ramanuja – As
per Sri Ramanuja’s Visishtadvaita
philosophy, all the three, Brahman, Jivas and Jagat, are Real. Jagat and Jivas form
part of Brahman as His body. Brahman
is similar to a tree with branches, leaves and fruits. The several parts like
leaves, branches etc., differ from one another while the tree itself remains as
‘one’ only. Brahman is the only one with independent Reality, while Jivas and
Jagat have only dependant Reality, their Reality depending on Brahman. As per
this philosophy, Lord Vishnu is the supreme Brahman who has three aspects:
Ishvara (Vishnu), Cit (soul) and Acit (matter). So Lord Vishnu is the only independent
Reality, while souls (Jivas) and
matter enjoy dependant Reality only. Jivas
are of three types; Nitya, eternally free, Muktha, free now but
once were in Samsara and Baddha, in Samsara and not free. Jivas
retain their identity even after Moksha and live in Fellowship with Lord
Vishnu, either serving Him or meditating on Him. Moksha is attained through liquidation
of one’s karmas achieved through total devotion to Lord Vishnu, characterised
by Saranagathi. Visishtadvaita
recognises only Videha Mukthi.
Dvaita of Sri Madhva – As
per Dvaita of Sri Madhva also Brahman is Lord
Vishnu and He only is independently Real.
Jivas, sentient souls
and Jada, insentient matter,
are also Real but their Reality is dependant Reality, dependant on Brahman; but they do not form part of Brahman as in Visishtadvaita.
The differences between Brahman
and Jiva, jiva and jada, jada and jada, jada and Brahman,
jiva and jiva, termed
Panchabheda, are an eternal fact. It also accepts three Pramanas
only: Pratyaksha, Anumana and Sabda. Jivas
are
of three clsseses; mukthi-yogas, eligible for Moksha, nitya-samsarins,
subject to eternal Samsara, tamo-yogyas, condemned to eternal
hell, the third group being unique to this system. Liberation is attaining the
lotus feet of Lord Vishnu and this can be attained only through pure devotional
service to Lord Vishnu.
Most
of the present sects of Hinduism are directly or indirectly influenced by the
thought systems developed by Vedantic
thinkers. So it is no exaggeration to say that Hinduism to a great extent owes
its survival to the formation of the coherent and logically advanced systems of
Vedanta.
-------------------